Doctrine & Formal Model

The Scutaria methodological framework

To remain defensible, compliance findings cannot rely on a black box. Every link in the reasoning chain must be made explicit.

Scutaria is an applied ontology of regulatory provenance, supported by an epistemology of attribution, evidence and contestability.

Applied Ontology

Structuring and linking objects

In Scutaria, an applied ontology designates an explicit and typed data model, oriented toward the traceability of regulatory provenance objects.

This model allows formal distinction between:

  • ✔ Official source and source passage
  • ✔ Working interpretation or requirement
  • ✔ Derived sub-obligation
  • ✔ Working mapping
  • ✔ Applicability decision
  • ✔ Evidence and evidence validation
  • ✔ Coverage
  • ✔ Human decision

It is not, however:

  • ✕ A complete formal logical ontology (e.g., OWL/RDF)
  • ✕ A legal inference engine or automated reasoner
  • ✕ A system capable of deciding compliance on its own
  • ✕ A replacement for human expertise
Methodological Chain

Objects of traceability

Detailed view of the six steps of the chain, including the source passage and working interpretation. Objects are distinct and sequential; they are never conflated into an abstract aggregate score.

  1. 01 Official source
  2. 02 Source passage
  3. 03 Working interpretation
  4. 04 Applicability decision
  5. 05 Evidence and validation
  6. 06 Coverage
  7. 07 Human decision
Epistemology of Provenance

Conditions for examinability

Scutaria’s epistemology does not claim to automatically produce legal truths. It focuses on the conditions under which a conclusion can be examined and, if necessary, contested.

  • Where does this requirement come from? On which exact source and passage does it rely?
  • What interpretation was formulated to apply it to the context?
  • By whom and on what date was an applicability decision made?
  • What evidence was examined, and for which specific sub-obligation?
  • What does this evidence cover, and what gaps remain?
  • What assumptions, reservations, or contestations persist?

AI assists; the human concludes.

Artificial intelligence and automation can aid in research and formulate proposals. But any conclusion is a human decision: it is attributed, dated, and recorded. It is not thereby infallible, legally certified, or electronically signed—it simply becomes transparent.

Dimensions of Provenance

Distinguishing text from incarnation

Rigorous traceability requires separating the legal dimension from the material dimension of a source.

Legal or normative identity

The abstract work, its version over time, its language, and its legal effective date.

Actually consulted file

The physical document, URL, cryptographic hash of the PDF, the page, and the exact date of consultation.

Interoperability and reference standards

  • Scutaria aims for alignment with ELI (European Legislation Identifier).
  • Scutaria aims for interoperability with Akoma Ntoso.
  • Scutaria may draw inspiration from provenance principles compatible with PROV, without claiming full PROV-O implementation.
Mappings

Connecting without forcing equivalence

A documentary mapping connects two objects to indicate an overlap or cross-interest.

Working mappings with documented rationale; their individual validation remains to be established.

  • Does not demonstrate a legal equivalence.
  • Does not constitute an exhaustive correspondence.
  • Does not replace an argued individual validation.
  • Does not automatically apply to all contexts.
In Practice

Methodological Demonstrations

Explore the conceptual framework through two fictitious scenarios.